Retirement Calculators / Resources / Pension planning
Same savings. Two answers.
Why pension calculators give different answers
Put the same pension into two calculators and one can make retirement look comfortable while the other leaves you wondering where the money went. Often, the difference is in the settings rather than your savings. Here’s how to find it, compare like with like and decide what the figures actually tell you.
The short answer
Two calculators usually disagree because they aren’t measuring the same thing. One might show a pot in future pounds. The other might show an income in today’s money. One might take off fees or raise your payments each year, and the other might not. Use the same inputs, compare the same result, and most of the gap usually goes away.
Inflation isn’t a fee taken out of your pension. It’s a way of translating future pounds into what they’d feel like now. Old inputs, unclear methods and plain mistakes can cause a gap too. That’s why matching the assumptions matters.
Planning figures only, not advice. The tax example uses 2026/27 rules for England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
What a pension calculator result actually means
Before you compare two tools, be clear what each number is. Two calculators can both be right and still disagree. One might show your pot at retirement. The other might show the first year’s income from that pot.
- Pot or income?Pot or Income
- How often?A year or A month
- Before or after tax?Gross or Spendable
- Which pounds?Future or Today’s
- Whose money?One person or Household
- What’s included?Private pension or All income
Why inflation makes the same pension look different
Prices tend to rise over time, so a pound buys less in future. A forecast in future pounds can look much bigger than the same forecast in today’s money. Nothing has been taken from the pot. It’s the same money, described two ways.
In the example below, £6,000 goes in every year. That amount never rises with inflation. On its own, that makes the today’s money result lower than a calculator that raises payments each year.
To see what inflation does to your own spending over time, try the Inflation Impact Calculator.
How growth, fees and the real return change a pension forecast
Three growth figures often get mixed up. Gross growth is what the investments earn before charges. Net growth is what’s left after charges. The real return is net growth after inflation, so it shows how fast your spending power grows.
This example uses 5% growth before charges. It takes off a 1% charge, leaving 4% net growth. Inflation is 2.5%. That’s a deliberately simple way to handle fees. If the 1% came off the balance after growth instead, net growth would be about 3.95%, not 4%. Providers charge in different ways.
When people say fees cost them a certain amount, they often mean two things added together. The charges themselves, plus the growth that money would have earned. That lost growth is a real difference. But it isn’t cash taken out of your account each year.
You can test growth and charges on your own pot with the Pension Account Growth Calculator.
Why retirement age changes a pension forecast
Retiring later usually means more paid in, more time to grow and fewer years to pay for. But retirement isn’t one moment. These four things can happen at different ages. A calculator that ties them together will disagree with one that keeps them apart.
Your State Pension age is set by law, not by your plan, and it may be years after you stop work. Our State Pension guides explain how it fits in.
How the income method changes the answer
There’s more than one way to turn a pot into income. You could take a set percentage in the first year. You could spend the pot evenly over a set number of years. Or you could get an annuity quote. Each one answers a different question, so you can’t swap their numbers. Real markets also go up and down. Poor returns early in retirement, while you’re taking money out, can do lasting damage. This is called sequence risk.
To see how a bad start could affect your own plan, try the Safe Withdrawal Rate Stress Tester. To weigh a flexible income against a guaranteed one, use the Drawdown vs Annuity Calculator.
All three below start from the same pot at 65: £242,754 in today’s money. The assumptions here are separate from the saving ones above. Amounts are yearly and before tax.
3% first-year withdrawal
£7,283This isn’t a guarantee or a “safe” rate.
4% first-year withdrawal
£9,710Check if later withdrawals rise with inflation.
Smooth 2% real return over 30 years
£10,839Taken at each year end. The pot runs out at the end.
For the spend-down example, yearly withdrawal = pot × 0.02 ÷ (1 − 1.02−n). Over 25 years instead, it would be about £12,434. These are before-tax figures with smooth returns and nothing left at the end. Smooth returns hide sequence risk.
Pension statements and online calculators follow different rules
Your pension statement
The statutory money purchase illustration on a defined contribution pension statement uses methods and assumptions set by the Financial Reporting Council’s AS TM1 standard. That does not mean every pension quotation or projection uses the same rules. Check the valuation date and whether your latest payments are included.
An online calculator
You choose your own growth, fees, inflation and income method. Not every calculator follows AS TM1. So the two can differ even with the same pot.
Defined benefit (DB) pensions work differently. They pay an income rather than building a pot. Cuts for retiring early and commutation, which means swapping some pension for cash, don’t fit a simple pot forecast. Compare DB statements on their own. If you’re weighing up a lump sum from a DB scheme, the DB Pension Lump Sum Calculator shows the trade-off.
How to compare pension calculators fairly
- Match the valuation date and starting pot.
- Match total payments in, including employer money and tax relief.
- Match retirement age and whether payments rise with inflation.
- State growth, fees and inflation once each.
- Match the income method and how many years it needs to last.
- Match how tax-free cash is treated.
- Match other income and when it starts.
- Name the exact result: pot, gross income, net income, today’s money or future pounds.
Change one setting at a time. Note down what you used. If the results still differ after that, read how each tool works. Don’t just trust whichever number looks nicer.
Worked example
Worked example: one saver, two answers
Age 45 · £100,000 pension · £6,000 a year going in · 4% net growth · 2.5% inflation
You’re 45 with £100,000 in a pension. At the end of each year, £6,000 goes in and that amount never changes. The £6,000 includes employer payments and tax relief, so it’s more than comes out of your take-home pay. Growth after charges is 4% and inflation is 2.5%. Nothing is taken out. There’s no State Pension, defined benefit pension or other savings in this part.
Future pot = £100,000 × 1.04n + £6,000 × ((1.04n − 1) ÷ 0.04)
Today’s-money pot = future pot ÷ 1.025n
n is the number of years until you retire. Only the final result is rounded.
Today’s-money pot by retirement age
| Retirement age | Years | Future pounds | Today’s money |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60 | 15 | £300,236 | £207,303 |
| 65 | 20 | £397,781 | £242,754 |
| 67 | 22 | £442,480 | £257,021 |
| 65 with no charges at 5% | 20 | £463,725 | £282,998 |
With no charges and 5% growth, the pot at 65 is £65,945 bigger in future pounds. That uses unrounded values. It includes the growth that was never earned, not just the charges. Take one rounded pot from the other and you get £65,944. A gap that small is just rounding.
Tax example
Tax example: one withdrawal in 2026/27
A separate example · same £242,754 pot, but held now in 2026/27 · England, Wales or Northern Ireland
A £9,710 pension withdrawal does not necessarily give you £9,710 to spend. Here’s the tax calculation for someone whose other income has already used their Personal Allowance.
Today’s tax bands can’t tell you the tax on a pot in 2046. So this example uses a different, made-up person. They hold the same £242,754 pot now, in 2026/27.
They already get £12,570 of other taxable pension income. That uses up the standard Personal Allowance, the amount you can earn each year before Income Tax. They then take £9,710.16 from pension money they haven’t touched before. A quarter is tax-free and the rest is taxable. We assume they have enough Lump Sum Allowance left, their provider offers this and they haven’t taken a separate tax-free lump sum before.
Tax-free part£2,427.54
Taxable part£7,282.62
Income Tax at 20%£1,456.52
Spendable withdrawal£8,253.64
Add the other £12,570 and their total income after tax is £20,823.64. The withdrawal adds about £688 a month after tax. With uncrystallised funds pension lump sums (UFPLS), successive withdrawals from untouched pension funds can usually each include a 25% tax-free part, subject to your remaining lump sum allowances. By contrast, after you take tax-free cash and move that portion into drawdown, later withdrawals from that drawdown portion are taxable. Taking an UFPLS normally triggers the money purchase annual allowance, restricting future tax-relieved defined contribution saving.
To run this with your own income, use the Pension Drawdown Tax Calculator.
Try it: compare two pension calculators side by side
Change the settings on two calculators and see how far apart the answers drift from the same saver.
Try it
Two calculators, one pension
Both calculators start with the same saver: aged 45, with £100,000 and £6,000 a year going in. Change any setting and watch the screens move apart. Then match B to A and see the gap close.
Calculator A
Calculator B
Calculator B shows more.
Settings that don’t match:
It assumes payments at the end of each year, the charge taken off growth as above, and smooth returns. It’s for learning, not a forecast. For your own figures, try the Retirement Income Calculator.
A practical next step
Pick one question you care about. That might be your pot at 65 in today’s money, or your income in the first year. Line up the settings above. Then compare tools on that one result. Calculators help you see the trade-offs. They give planning figures, not a personal recommendation.
You can stress-test inflation with the Inflation Impact Calculator, compare fund costs with the Index Fund Comparison Calculator and weigh up income styles with the Drawdown vs Annuity Calculator. To sketch spendable income, try the Retirement Income Calculator, and to check tax-free cash, the Tax-Free Lump Sum Calculator.
Keep your settings in one place
Keep a note of the assumptions beside your pensions, savings and spending in Plan Hub. Use that note when entering figures into another calculator, then check its defaults rather than assuming it uses the same settings.
Common questions
Why do pension calculators give different answers for the same pot?
They may use different growth, fees, inflation, payment rises, retirement ages, income methods or tax rules. They may also show different things. One might show future pounds and the other today’s money. One might show a pot and the other an income.
Why is my pension statement lower than an online calculator?
The statutory money purchase illustration on a defined contribution pension statement follows AS TM1, the Financial Reporting Council’s standard. Other pension quotations and projections may use different rules. An online calculator may use higher growth, lower fees or a later retirement age. Check both are showing today’s money and the same retirement age before you compare them.
Is today’s money more honest than future pounds?
Today’s money shows what the pot would buy now. Future pounds show how many pounds may sit in the account. Both are useful if they’re clearly labelled. The trouble starts when you compare one tool’s future pounds with another tool’s today’s money. The Inflation Impact Calculator shows how big that gap gets.
Does a higher forecast mean a better calculator?
No. A higher number may just mean higher growth, lower fees, rising payments, a later retirement age or a more hopeful income method. Match the assumptions before you judge the tool. To see how much fees alone can change things, try the Index Fund Comparison Calculator.
Which pension calculator should I trust?
Look for clear methods, current rules and results you can reconcile with a worked example. Understanding the assumptions matters, but liking the result doesn’t make a calculator accurate. Look for a tool that tells you its growth, fees and inflation, and says whether results are in today’s money. Use the checklist above, then try your own numbers in the Retirement Income Calculator and see what changes.
Are there hidden costs in online pension calculators?
Separate the cost of using the tool from the costs inside your pension. Check whether access is free, paid or part of a subscription, then look for fund, platform and advice charges in the calculation. Check tax and inflation too: omitting them can make an otherwise correct calculation unsuitable for your question. If a provider asks for contact details, check what you’re signing up to. Compare the assumptions and methods, not just the headline result.
See more from us on Google
Choose Retirement Calculators as a preferred source and Google is more likely to show you our guides in Top Stories when you search. It only takes a moment.
(opens in a new tab)Sources
- Financial Reporting Council: AS TM1, the rules for pension statement projections
- GOV.UK: Income Tax rates and Personal Allowances
- GOV.UK: Tax on your private pension
- GOV.UK: Lump Sum Allowance
Planning figures only, not advice. Tax bands, AS TM1 assumptions and State Pension rates change. Check them before relying on any dated example.